Mendocino Presbyterian Church
44831 Main Street, Mendocino — An 1867-1868 redwood Gothic church above Mendocino Bay, California Historical Landmark No. 714.
Last updated: November 12, 2026
Overview

The tall white steeple of the Mendocino Presbyterian Church has stood over the village for more than 150 years. The congregation organized in 1859, and the present redwood Gothic sanctuary was built above Mendocino Bay in 1867–1868. It is California Historical Landmark No. 714 and still holds Sunday services. Residents remember weddings, Boy Scout meetings, a youth center in the early 1960s, and the church's role in the film Johnny Belinda.
According to the earlier website history, it is one of California's oldest Protestant churches in continuous use. It has a steep roof, Gothic windows, a steeple about 78 feet tall, and a sanctuary ceiling shaped like the upturned hull of a ship. Its bell, bought in 1870 and weighing about 1,000 pounds, still rings for Sunday services.
Location
The church stands on Main Street near the headlands, overlooking Mendocino Bay. Its main entrance originally faced the old Coast Road coming up from the Big River flats. One resident puts it this way: the "front door" is around back, facing what was once a street south of Main.
History
The following history comes from the earlier website history, which drew on the church archive, the Kelley House Museum, and state landmark records.
In 1858, Jerome B. Ford and William Heeser collected subscriptions for Mendocino's first Presbyterian church, a small building at Lansing and Ukiah streets. The congregation organized in 1859 with eight charter members. Construction of the present sanctuary began on October 7, 1867. S.C. Bugbee and Son of San Francisco designed it, and contractor Albert Maxwell built it from redwood milled in Mendocino. Ford donated the land and paid half of the roughly $10,000 cost. The church was dedicated on July 5, 1868. In 1870, Ford bought a Meneely bell from West Troy, New York, and had it shipped around Cape Horn.
Warner Bros. filmed Johnny Belinda on the coast in 1947 and used the church as a location. Jane Wyman won the Academy Award for Best Actress for her role in the film. One resident shared an interior still of the sanctuary from the film. The church was designated California Historical Landmark No. 714 in 1959, the congregation's centennial year. Local artist Leone McNeil Zimmer added memorial stained-glass windows in the late 1970s and 1980s, and a large Zimmer window was dedicated in 1990.
Timeline
1858 — Subscriptions are collected for the first Presbyterian church.
1859 — The congregation organizes with eight charter members.
1867 — Construction of the present sanctuary begins on October 7.
1868 — The church is dedicated on July 5.
1870 — The Meneely bell arrives around Cape Horn.
1947 — Johnny Belinda is filmed on the coast, with scenes at the church.
1959 — The church becomes California Historical Landmark No. 714.
1990 — A large Zimmer memorial window is dedicated.
Community Memories
From 1945 to 1955, one resident's family walked up from the Big River flats to attend services. Another resident remembers David Ng and the youth center in the early 1960s. Another went to Boy Scout meetings there in ninth grade. One resident attended church there during high school, from 1979 to 1981, and stopped by in June to take a photo, finding it still beautiful.
One resident was married in the church, and another resident's cousin married there in the 1970s. Another resident shared a photo of the church's other side. For one resident, it comes down to two words: "My church."
Why It Matters
For more than 150 years, the Mendocino Presbyterian Church has been both a landmark and an active congregation. It was built of local redwood with Jerome Ford's support, and its steeple still draws the eye across the village. Generations of coast families have worshiped, married, and gathered there.
For more local history, photographs, and archived articles, explore the complete Fort Bragg History collection. See the full archive: www.infortbragg.com
Sources & Original Research
This article blends verifiable historical records with personal recollections shared by longtime Fort Bragg residents. Much of this information comes from community memory and is not available in any published source.
Original Buildings and Businesses on the Mendocino Coast, California — With History posts and photographs, Gee Bee's Adventures.
Earlier InFortBragg.com article, which cited the Mendocino Presbyterian Church historical archive; the Kelley House Museum's "Mendocino Presbyterian Church - Then and Now"; California Office of Historic Preservation records for California Historical Landmark No. 714; and Mendocino Coast Chamber of Commerce motion-picture location records.
Facebook community recollections from: India Gingell, Chuck Ross, Lucas Macmath, Ron Witt, Stephanie Tinney Langston, Scott Harris, Michael Duffy, Tom Fields, Bill Behrns, and Mary E Hanke.
