The Stewart House
511 Stewart St. — Locally claimed as the first civilian house built in Fort Bragg (1876), part of the town's oldest-home debate with the Weller House.
Last updated: November 5, 2026
Overview

The small house at 511 Stewart Street is locally known as the Stewart House. Property listings date it to 1876, which would make it one of Fort Bragg's earliest civilian homes. One resident has always heard it called the oldest house in town, but the nearby Weller House has the stronger official record for that title.
According to the earlier website history, several real estate and property listings give the Stewart House a construction date of 1876 and describe it as the first civilian house built in Fort Bragg. It is a private residence, not a museum or public landmark.
Location
The house is on Stewart Street, in one of Fort Bragg's older residential neighborhoods, near the Weller House at 524 Stewart Street.
History
The 1876 date comes from property listings and has not been confirmed by a historic survey or building record. Who built the house has not been established.
According to the earlier website history, the Weller House was built in 1886 and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Nomination material and later references have called it the oldest house in Fort Bragg.
The thread's author explains the difference this way. The Stewart House has the earlier claimed date, but it is a private home and is not widely documented in historic inventories. The Weller House has National Register recognition, so it is often described as the town's oldest or most significant historic house. That claim holds in a preservation sense, even if the Weller House was not the first house built.
Community Memories
One resident has always heard the house called the oldest in town and remembers it as the Hautala house. Another resident loves the little house, and a third thanked the thread's author for explaining the two claims.
Why It Matters
The Stewart House shows how the oldest claimed date and the strongest official record can point to different buildings. Whether it proves to be Fort Bragg's first civilian house or simply one of its earliest, it is a reminder of the town's first residential years.
For more local history, photographs, and archived articles, explore the complete Fort Bragg History collection.
See the full archive: www.infortbragg.com
Sources & Original Research
This article blends verifiable historical records with personal recollections shared by longtime Fort Bragg residents. Much of this information comes from community memory and is not available in any published source.
Original Buildings and Businesses in Fort Bragg, California — With History posts and photographs, Gee Bee's Adventures.
Earlier InFortBragg.com article, which cited Zillow, Realtor.com, Redfin, and Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices listings for 511 Stewart Street; the National Register and NoeHill records for the Weller House; Weller House official history; and the HMdb Weller House marker entry.
Facebook community recollections from: Gee Bee, Nancy Beck, Laura Schroeder, India Gingell, and Janet Del Fiorentino Lewis.
